Skip to content

Journal Article

Earnings and income penalties for motherhood: estimates for British women using the individual synthetic control method

Authors

Publication date

22 Jul 2021

Summary

Using data from the British Household Panel Survey and focusing on women who became mothers between 1995 and 2005, we estimate the motherhood penalty for women’s own earnings and for the total income of their household: that is, we consider the extent to which motherhood carries a penalty not only for a mother but also for her family. We adopt an approach that differs from those previously employed in research on motherhood penalties: we follow Hernán and Robins, setting up our data as a ‘target trial’, and we analyse it using the Individual Synthetic Control method, based on the Synthetic Control approach of Abadie, Diamond and Hainmueller. We find considerable variation in the effect of motherhood on British women’s earnings, but the median penalty is a reduction in medium- and long-term earnings by about 45 per cent relative to what women would have earned if they had remained childless. Motherhood has no effect on average on the income of the woman’s household, but has substantial negative effects for some households. Focusing on both individual and household penalties yields a more complete picture of the distributional consequences of motherhood than hitherto.

Published in

European Sociological Review

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1093/esr/jcab014

ISSN

16

Subjects

Labour Market, Households, Childbearing: Fertility, Income Dynamics, Wages And Earnings, Household Economics, Life Course Analysis, and Sociology

Notes

Open Access; © The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com


Related publications

  1. The cost of motherhood: women face 'pay penalty' of 45% lower earnings in the six years after giving birth to their first child, study shows

    Giacomo Vagni and Richard Breen

    1. Labour Market
    2. Households
    3. Childbearing: Fertility
    4. Income Dynamics
    5. Wages And Earnings
    6. Household Economics
    7. Life Course Analysis
    8. Sociology
  2. Women face ‘motherhood penalty’ of up to 45 per cent lower earnings

    Giacomo Vagni and Richard Breen

    1. Labour Market
    2. Households
    3. Childbearing: Fertility
    4. Income Dynamics
    5. Wages And Earnings
    6. Household Economics
    7. Life Course Analysis
    8. Sociology
  3. Women face 45% ‘motherhood penalty’ on earnings

    Giacomo Vagni and Richard Breen

    1. Labour Market
    2. Households
    3. Childbearing: Fertility
    4. Income Dynamics
    5. Wages And Earnings
    6. Household Economics
    7. Life Course Analysis
    8. Sociology
  4. ‘Motherhood penalty’ cuts earnings by up to 45%

    Giacomo Vagni and Richard Breen

    1. Labour Market
    2. Households
    3. Childbearing: Fertility
    4. Income Dynamics
    5. Wages And Earnings
    6. Household Economics
    7. Life Course Analysis
    8. Sociology

#536902


Research home

Research home

News

Latest findings, new research

Publications search

Search all research by subject and author

Podcasts

Researchers discuss their findings and what they mean for society

Projects

Background and context, methods and data, aims and outputs

Events

Conferences, seminars and workshops

Survey methodology

Specialist research, practice and study

Taking the long view

ISER's annual report

Themes

Key research themes and areas of interest