Skip to content

Journal Article

Predicting which people with psychosocial distress are at risk of becoming dependent on state benefits: analysis of routinely available data

Authors

Publication date

2010

Abstract

Objectives:
To examine whether there was significant variation in levels of claiming incapacity benefit across general practices. To establish whether it is possible to identify people with mental health problems who are more at risk of becoming dependent on state benefits for long term health problems based on their general practice consulting behaviour.
Design:
Interrogation of routinely available data in the Scottish Health Surveys and the British Household Panel Survey.
Setting:
Scotland and the United Kingdom.
Participants:
Respondents to the Scottish Health Surveys in 1995, 1998, and 2003 (7932, 12 939 and 11 472 respondents, respectively). Respondents to the British Household Panel Survey, 1991-2007 (more than 5000 households).
Main outcome measures:
Intracluster correlation coefficient for probability of work incapacity by general practice. Caseness according to the general health questionnaire (GHQ-12) and frequency of consultation with general practitioner in years before and after starting to claim incapacity benefit.
Results:
There was a small and non-significant amount of variation across general practices in Scotland in rate of claims for incapacity benefit after adjustment for other explanatory variables (intracluster correlation coefficient 0.01, P=0.135). There was a significant increase in rates of GHQ-12 caseness from two years before the start of claiming incapacity benefit (odds ratio 1.6, 95% confidence interval 1.3 to 1.9) and an increase in frequent consultation with a general practitioner from three years before the start of claiming incapacity benefit (1.8, 1.3 to 2.4). People with GHQ-12 caseness showed a significant increase in frequent consultations with a general practitioner from two years before the start of claiming incapacity benefit (2.1, 1.4 to 3.2).
Conclusions:
There was no variation in levels of claiming incapacity benefit across general practices in Scotland after adjustment for differences in population characteristics and so initiatives targeted at practices with high levels are unlikely to be effective. People with mental health problems who are likely to have problems remaining in work can be identified up to three years before they transit on to long term benefits related to ill health.

Published in

British Medical Journal

Volume

341 (171):c3838

DOI

http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.c3838

Subjects

Disability, Unemployment, Welfare Benefits, and Health

Links

http://serlib0.essex.ac.uk/record=b1584178~S5

Notes

BioMed alert; NCBI alert; EBSCO EPAlerts; Albert Sloman Library Periodicals *restricted to Univ. Essex registered users*


Related publications

  1. Studies from University of Glasgow yield new information about mental health

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  2. GPs 'could help identify claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  3. Returning long-term sick to work

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  4. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  5. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  6. Significant increase in GP consultations for mental health: research

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  7. Call for GPs to monitor mental health benefits

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  8. GPs to help tackle benefit dependency

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  9. GPs 'could help prevent mental health benefits culture'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  10. Long-term mental health problems 'could be spotted three years in advance'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  11. GPs 'can spot long-term sick three years early'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  12. GPs 'could spot patients at risk of benefit dependency'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  13. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  14. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  15. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  16. GPs could identity long-term sick in advance

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  17. GPs could spot long-term sick 'while at work'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  18. GPs 'could spot patients at risk of benefit dependency'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  19. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  20. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  21. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  22. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  23. GPs 'could help identify claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  24. GPs 'could help identify claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  25. GPs 'could help identify claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  26. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  27. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  28. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  29. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  30. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  31. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  32. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  33. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  34. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  35. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  36. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  37. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  38. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  39. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  40. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  41. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  42. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  43. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  44. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  45. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  46. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  47. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  48. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  49. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  50. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  51. GPs 'could help identity claimants'

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  52. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  53. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  54. Long-term sick could be identified 3 years prior to going on benefit

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

  55. Studies from University of Glasgow yield new information about mental health

    William Whittaker, Matthew Sutton, Margaret Maxwell, et al.

#513748


Research home

Research home

News

Latest findings, new research

Publications search

Search all research by subject and author

Podcasts

Researchers discuss their findings and what they mean for society

Projects

Background and context, methods and data, aims and outputs

Events

Conferences, seminars and workshops

Survey methodology

Specialist research, practice and study

Taking the long view

ISER's annual report

Themes

Key research themes and areas of interest